Book Review: The Aeronaut’s Windlass

The Aeronaut’s Windlass (The Cinder Spires #1)

by Jim Butcher.

The Aeronaut's Windlass Jim Butcher is one of my favorite authors (The Dresden Files! The Codex Alera!), so when I heard he was writing a new YA-ish steampunk series, I couldn’t wait to jump in.

This first book in the series introduces us to the world of the Spires, floating cities high in the air where humanity has lived for eons. This is Earth’s humanity, far into the future- something has happened on the surface to make ground life inhospitable. The Spire inhabitants engage in the usual political and mercantile pursuits, and fly around on very cool sounding airships. There’s a good amount of gadgetry mixed in with a good bit of magic. Spire Albion is where most of the story takes place, and we’re dropped in right as war with neighboring Spire Aurora heats up. There’s intrigue afoot, and hints of an ancient evil rising, and naturally our band of characters is vital to unraveling and stopping it. The worldbuilding is a bit on the sparse side, but not to the point of it interfering with the story. I expect that will get fleshed out in coming books.

It’s not quite YA, though. There are a couple of characters who are coming-of-age age: Gwen, the daughter of one of the most powerful families, and Bridget, a humble butcher’s daughter. The sections from their POV definitely fit the YA bill. But there’s also some fully adult characters who get their turn at POV, most notably Grimm, the airship captain arguably at the heart of story. Possibly my favorite sections were those from Rowl’s POV- who is, by the way, a cat. It seems like it’d be gimmicky, but somehow it’s not. And the whole feline warrior culture was entertaining. Butcher has clearly made an in-depth study of cats.

Overall, this was a really fun read, not particularly heavy going or light going. I’m not sure it has quite the storytelling pull that his other two series have- at least not yet. But it’s a solid opening book for what I’m sure will be a steampunk-y and epic adventure, and I fully plan on reading the next book to see where it goes.

I give it 4/5 stars.

Buy From Amazon

The Aeronaut's Windlass


Hi, I’m Amanda!

I’m a self-employed graphic designer by day, and a crafty hungry bookworm by night. Dragonflight Dreams is where I write about books, recipes, internet goodies, life things, crafty projects, Austin happenings, and more.

Thanks for stopping by!

Currently Reading

The Surviving Sky
Be: A No-Bullsh*t Guide to Increasing Your Self Worth and Net Worth by Simply Being Yourself
Cloud Cuckoo Land
Ghostland: An American History in Haunted Places
Chillpreneur: The New Rules for Creating Success, Freedom, and Abundance on Your Terms
Thinking, Fast and Slow

Amanda's favorite books »

2023 Reading Challenge

2023 Reading Challenge

2023 Reading Challenge
Amanda has completed her goal of reading 75 books in 2023!

Types of Happenings